Sunday 2 August 2015

A critical evaluation on Samkya system for the Students of Bacaularate in Philoosphy



“एष ते अभिहित संख्ये युद्धिः योगे तु इमं शृणु 
बुद्ध्य युक्तो यया पार्थ करमा बन्धं प्रहास्यसि “ ।। ( श्लोक ३९ )

“The ideal of self knowledge has been presented to you. Prepare to practice it. Endowed with it, you will break bonds of Karma.” (B.G, Chp.2- Samkya Yoga - Sloka 39)

Introduction

The six Vedic systems that constitute the Indian philosophy highlight the essential importance and existence of the Major philosophy of ancient India (Samkya). Samkya Philosophy in its rich contributions from and to the scholars and students alike helps for a detailed and deep study of Indian structure of systems and real Knowledge for the liberation. Samkya gains the meaning of the word primarily as the “right knowledge” and secondly the philosophy of “Numbers”, believed to be founded by sage Kapila (200 BCE).Samkya is one way can be alleged as the living force of Indian Philosophy as it is in Theistic nature. At times we come across this uniqueness in the classical Samkya erudition as we run through the authoritative works. The dualistic principle of Samkya, clearly elucidate the dependence on God of the soul/souls and the world. The origin and the nature of original Samkya have been controversial and scholars of great eminence both eastern and western have endowed their best attention to these. The present study of Samkya philosophy is invigorated only with the help of the work Samkyakarika by Ishvarakrishna which is systematic and ancient, believed to be composed in the 9th century C.E. Here the study of a scholastic done with the help of Samkyakarika is undertaken not only to prove the soundness of the system instead to establish also the inadequacies to satisfy a philosophical quest. Tough much of the Samkya literature is lost it is not the avowed formulation of the religious experiences in which the Vedanta is primarily not analytical and critical like Nyaya. The study in this assignment comprises the key three aspects prearranged in the philosophy of Samkya viz. the Purusha and Prakrti, the three Gunas and the theory of causality. We can conclude the search in Samkya saying that it is based on the speculative insight and demands, imaginative and introspective effort at every stage on the part of the interpreter we approach Samkya to get hold of genuine or real knowledge.

Samkya in Indian Philosophical teachings.

The Hindu philosophy at a convinced extend lost the charisma of Samkya philosophy in her knowledge and propagations of teachings. Though this nonexistence is clear it is not as explicit and lucid as the absence of Buddhism from the terra firma of its birth, India. Samkya unlike Buddhism being an orthodox system of knowledge is advocated and absorbed by most of the Indian philosophical streams and it is difficult to read an Indian philosophical article or work free from the attendance of Samkya wisdom and stuffs pertaining to poles apart knowledge on philosophy, religion or mythology. As burgeoning scholars Samkya is believed to be not as the off shoot of Upanishadhic Vedanta, as an alternative it should be understood as the off shoot of Upanishadhic Literature itself. Indian philosophical explanations are mostly constructed up on the lessons of Samkya and other systems. The derivation always lies in the 6 systems which alter the study from philosophy to spiritual in its subterranean sense.

The philosophy of Samkya Karika

The extant work on the philosophical studies of Samkya is the most ancient work of Ishvarakrishna namely Samkya Karika. It speaks the realistic – dualism or pluralism of the Samkya philosophy. Samkya considers everything as to be real both spirit and non spirit. Vedanta schools of Ramanuja and Madhva disseminate the idea of plurality of souls both in their bound state and liberated state. Atheism is a proliferated concept in the philosophy of Samkya. Atheism of Samkya is never denied the authority of the Vedas as do the Jainas and the Buddhas. Liberation through the discriminative knowledge and the acquisition of real knowledge through three means viz. perception (Pratyaksha), Inference (Anumana), and verbal testimony (Sabdha/ Sastra).The most important philosophy is the concept of Absolute dualism, Purusha and Prakrti, three Gunas ,the idea of causality and the 25 principles evolved from Prakrti.

v  Purusha and Prakrti.

The dualistic principle flourished in the Samkya philosophy talks about the two absolute independent eternal being called by the name Purusha and Prakrti. Purusha is the pure consciousness and mere witness of everything (saksi). It is the inactive principle and does nothing enjoy nonentity. Where as Prakrti or (Avyakta or Pradhana) is unborn and eternally existing by the side of Purusha. Prakrti is the name of Noumenal condition’ of all that exists apart from the self and that comes to our experience. Mula- Prakrti the root nature and Pradhana or the first or primordial cause.

v  The twenty five principles

Samkya is the philosophy of 25 principles which is categorized in to two. The self and the non self or the Purusha and the Prakrti. The Prakrti and her evolutes constitute the 24 principles:
Prakrti, (The primeval or primordial matter the cause of the existence and evolution of this Universe).
i.            Mahat or Buddhi, (the intelligence principle the first manifestation of Prakrti. It is the discriminating and determining principle. (SK.23). Sattva is the predominant factor and Mahat generates Ahamkara.)
ii.            Ahamkara, (this principle is believed to be the creator of egoism. It delude Purusha to think that “he is doing all the actions“or “he exists” this principle fruits in the worth image of ‘self conscious’, Abhimana.)
iii.            Manas or mind (the vaikrta transformation of Ahamkara is termed as Manas. It enjoys both the fruits of cognition and actions. It is cognitive in the sense it is “samkalpakam“ mind is also an indriya which functions as both buddhindriyas and karmendriays
iv.            Five Jnanendriyas, (eyes, tongue, nose, ear skin or touch).
v.            Five karmendriays ( Hands, feet, Speech, genital (organs of generation) and Anus (organ of Excretion)
vi.            Five tanmatras ( Earth, Water, Air, fire, and space or Akasa)
vii.            Five Mahabhuthas. ( Earth, Water, Air, fire, and space or Akasa)

All these 24 principles bring forth the concept of ‘object’ (Vishaya: SK.11), in relation with the 25th principle the Purusha is the knowing ‘subject’ (Jna: SK.2)

v  The Three Gunas

The theory of Parinama is the basis on which the Philosophy of the Nature of the Samkya is developed. This Parinama is in another way known as the transformation of the unmanifest Prakrti the first cause of the Universe (as per one of the standard text of Indian Philosophy) in to a manifest or the phenomenal world. The three Gunas are viz.
(i)                 Sattva (that which exist or real) Pertaining to the quality or attributes of Luminosity, Knowledge, goodness etc.
(ii)               Rajas (foulness) which deal the activities, motion and energy. It stimulates and produces the pain.
(iii)             Tamas (Darkness) speaks about the principles of inertia, darkness, evilness, passivity, negativity etc. these three Gunas are considers as the essence e of Prakrti and the heterogeneous activity causes the evolution from the Prakrti in the presence of Purusha.


v  Theory of Causation

The entire universe is considered as the evolutes of Prakrti by the disturbance of three Gunas. But the theory of sat-karya-vada argues that the effect is pre existed in the cause and the present affirmation of an object is just the modification of that existence. But there are scholars who refute the idea of sat karya vada by explaining the theory of Asatkaryavada..

Critical appraisal on Samkya Philosophy

·         The decisive study of each and every discipline would bring forth tremendous amount of knowledge as well s the dubious or not up to scratch elements to the seeker. The salient features of Samkya are well appreciated as per the study done by the help of Samkyakarika.
·         The study led me personally to say that the exemplary evidences in Samkya dealing with the unsound rationalism are pervasive and plays prominent role throughout the literature.
·         The other dilemma fell on the Samkya philosophy is the fundamental principle of dualism and it’s below par to accept as true or the inaccuracy to put in to a sensible mind.
·         The insentient Pradhana can’t be a material cause for the inanimate as well as animate objects in this world.
·         Also the spontaneous actions of the three Gunas, the essence of Prakrti is untenable. Where are the possibilities to encompass Prakrti the eternal and divine principle, as the abode of these three diverse and divergent Guans with multiple qualities? Questions cram the psyche and crave for the reasonable retort instead of hypotheses.

Conclusion

Samkya as the early or ancient and the classical philosophy of India that enhanced and rejuvenated the spirituality of Indian Sages and rishis has a great to do with, even in this 21st century. The teachings of discovering the inner self of man or the inner essence of man resulting in the conception of Atman as the real self and the discovery of Brahman as the source and reason for the contrast with the self and the non self is all are the significance of the study of Samkya. She took by hand many since ever her origin through Kapila and down to centuries she does the same. Apart from the venture to identify the real charisma hidden in the Samkya philosophy it helps to have a real knowledge that is based on real cues provided by the sense organs and all other factors that assist the rationality. Knowledge that discriminative can help to attain the stage of Kaivalaya as everything in the phenomenal world seeks for, as the aim or goal all the way through in the mere existence in this world.

Bibliography.

1)      Rao Ramakrishna, Theism of Pre-Classical Samkya, Mysore: Prasaranga University of Mysore, 1966.
2)      Anima Sen Gupta, Classical Samkya A Critical Study, New Delhi: Munshiram Manoharlal Publishers, 1982.

prepared by,

Bro Sebin Varghese moonjely B.
Barnabite Vidya Bhavan
Bangalore 

a student of 
Dharmaram Vidya Kshetram
Bangalore



No comments:

Post a Comment